In a clinical microbiology laboratory, bacterial identification techniques are of fundamental importance. They enable laboratory personnel to identify the bacteria present in a given biological sample, thereby guiding clinicians toward the optimal therapeutic choice to safeguard a patient's health. For this very reason, it has been crucial to continuously enhance the performance of these identification techniques, aiming to obtain specific and accurate results as quickly as possible. This study compares two identification technologies—the most widely used methods in clinical microbiology laboratories: MALDI-TOF technology and rapid biochemical identification. The former is based on MALDI-TOF (Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization-Time of Flight) mass spectrometry, which generates a mass spectrum of the bacterium’s surface proteins—a spectrum that is specific to each bacterial species. Rapid phenotypic identification, on the other hand, relies on the biochemical and phenotypic characteristics of bacteria. This method employs an instrument known as Vitek, which uses specialized panels containing miniaturized tests. These tests include various substrates that, when metabolized by the bacteria, produce a biochemical profile used for identification. To compare these two identification techniques, 26 strains of *Enterobacteriaceae* were used. These Gram-negative bacteria, belonging to the order *Enterobacterales*, are frequently encountered in biological samples; some species within the genus *Enterobacter* are opportunistic pathogens found in the human gut microbiota. *Enterobacter* strains are particularly challenging to identify due to the high complexity of this genus. *Enterobacter* strains were isolated from biological samples, cultured on MacConkey agar, and simultaneously tested using both identification techniques, starting from pure bacterial colonies. The study demonstrated that the results obtained via MALDI-TOF technology were achieved in significantly less time—both in terms of the preparation required for the identification system and the actual analysis time. Furthermore, the results showed greater specificity compared to those obtained using the Vitek system.
All’interno di un laboratorio di microbiologia clinica, di fondamentale importanza sono le tecniche d’identificazione batterica, che permettono agli operatori di riconoscere il batterio presente all’interno di un determinato campione biologico, così da orientare il clinico nella migliore scelta terapeutica per salvaguardare la salute di un paziente. Proprio per questo motivo è stato fondamentale rendere sempre più performanti queste tecniche d’identificazione, così da ottenere nel minor tempo possibile risultati specifici ed accurati. In questo studio sono state confrontate due tecnologie d’identificazione, nonché le più utilizzate all’interno dei laboratori di microbiologia clinica: la tecnologia MALDI-ToF e l’identificazione biochimica rapida. La prima, si basa sulla spettrometria di massa MALDI-ToF (Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization-Time of Flight), che permette di ottenere uno spettro di massa delle proteine di superficie del batterio, specifico per le diverse specie batteriche. Per quanto riguarda la tecnologia di identificazione fenotipica rapida, questa si basa sulle caratteristiche biochimiche e fenotipiche dei batteri, attraverso l’utilizzo di uno strumento denominato Vitek. Questo utilizza dei pannelli specifici, all’interno dei quali sono presenti test miniaturizzati contenenti diversi substrati che, una volta utilizzati dai batteri, permettono di ottenere un profilo biochimico utile all’identificazione. Per confrontare queste due tecniche di identificazione sono stati utilizzati 26 ceppi di Enterobacter. Questi batteri Gram -, appartenenti alla famiglia Enterobacterales, sono spesso riscontrabili in campioni biologici, in quanto alcune specie appartenenti al genere Enterobacter sono patogeni opportunisti presenti nel microbiota intestinale umano. I ceppi di Enterobacter risultano particolarmente difficili da identificare a causa dell’elevata complessità di questo genere. I ceppi di Enterobacter sono stati isolati da campioni biologici e seminati su terreni di Mac Conkey, e testati contemporaneamente con le due tecniche di identificazione a partire da colonie batteriche pure. Lo studio ci ha mostrato come i risultati ottenuti dalla tecnologia MALDI-ToF siano stati raggiunti in tempi nettamente minori, sia per quanto riguarda i tempi d’allestimento del sistema di identificazione, che come tempi d’analisi. Inoltre, i risultati hanno evidenziato specificità maggiore rispetto a quelli del Vitek
Sistemi di identificazione batterica: analisi comparativa tra due metodologie su ceppi di Enterobacter spp
BARCHIESI, CHIARA
2025/2026
Abstract
In a clinical microbiology laboratory, bacterial identification techniques are of fundamental importance. They enable laboratory personnel to identify the bacteria present in a given biological sample, thereby guiding clinicians toward the optimal therapeutic choice to safeguard a patient's health. For this very reason, it has been crucial to continuously enhance the performance of these identification techniques, aiming to obtain specific and accurate results as quickly as possible. This study compares two identification technologies—the most widely used methods in clinical microbiology laboratories: MALDI-TOF technology and rapid biochemical identification. The former is based on MALDI-TOF (Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization-Time of Flight) mass spectrometry, which generates a mass spectrum of the bacterium’s surface proteins—a spectrum that is specific to each bacterial species. Rapid phenotypic identification, on the other hand, relies on the biochemical and phenotypic characteristics of bacteria. This method employs an instrument known as Vitek, which uses specialized panels containing miniaturized tests. These tests include various substrates that, when metabolized by the bacteria, produce a biochemical profile used for identification. To compare these two identification techniques, 26 strains of *Enterobacteriaceae* were used. These Gram-negative bacteria, belonging to the order *Enterobacterales*, are frequently encountered in biological samples; some species within the genus *Enterobacter* are opportunistic pathogens found in the human gut microbiota. *Enterobacter* strains are particularly challenging to identify due to the high complexity of this genus. *Enterobacter* strains were isolated from biological samples, cultured on MacConkey agar, and simultaneously tested using both identification techniques, starting from pure bacterial colonies. The study demonstrated that the results obtained via MALDI-TOF technology were achieved in significantly less time—both in terms of the preparation required for the identification system and the actual analysis time. Furthermore, the results showed greater specificity compared to those obtained using the Vitek system.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
TESI BARCHIESI CHIARA.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
2.58 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.58 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12075/29946